Rip asked me to test the SHO pump when he first started to offer it. I ran it for about 6 months. I liked it alot. When my current VP44 goes bad, that's what I'm going to put back on.
The surge that I had was more like a slight lope. My girl friend said it made my truck sound "mean". We played with different offset keys to change the static timing (I know there is currently another thread on that subject), but the "stock" key it came with performed the best for me at the drag strip.
For most people the SO pump is the best bang for the buck. It's hard to justify the extra money for a SHO (hot rod) pump.
Not all of the hot rod pumps are the same. It's not just a change of electronics. At one time I know most of the hot rod pumps were using the cam out of a HO pump and the pistons out of a SO. This gave high lift, and large pistons. That was part of the expense. You needed two pumps to make one.
Paul