Diesel importer, I broke 2 stock flexplates, so I bought a laminated one. (from source automotive) It didn't make it a week, the stockers lasted a couple years. It looked like bad welds to me (as that's where it separated, didn't actually rip in two, but the center let go at all the welds), but they were really good about it and warrantied it without hesitation, but I didn't want to risk it so I sold the new one and put in a billet one instead. My truck is probably 650 rwhp, so not huge power.
As for a sound, the first one grenaded at WOT and I thought I threw a rod out the block. Second stocker sounded like a bent valve or leaky exhaust gasket (think helicopter) and the laminated one had a constant tick to it. So far so good with the billet....only bad thing is I don't know what my "fuse" is going to be now...