malibu795
2wd numb nut
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2007
- Messages
- 6,731
Actually, the most accurate answer would be "it depends"
If both trucks are the same weight and both vehicles have gearing that "optimizes" the power curve of each engine..... the race would be very close if not a dead heat.
the difference being as noted above is that the power curve for diesel engines is a lot closer to "optimum" with street gearing than compared to a gasser that requires a lot of RPM to make good power. A gasser would require a higher stall converter, lower gears, etc. Then a gasser with the same HP would be competitive with a diesel at the track, it just would not have the same good manners on the street that a diesel has.
For example, if you hang a turbo on an otherwise stock gas truck to get 500hp, the gasser would lose in a quarter mile race, swap out the R&P for 4.88 gears and a 3.5k converter and its a whole new ball game.
But thats the beauty of diesel is that you not only can have your cake and eat it too, you can have ice cream on the side... Power, good street manners & better mileage
GM did it with the dmax(310/605) and the 8.1 vortec(340hp/455lb) both ran 5 speed allison and TC to match both motors... yet the diesel was faster at the stripe in stock form..
even with 4.10 gears option for the 8.1 it still isnt faster then diesel.. but you say since the 8.1 has 30 HP more it "should" be faster it even make power at a higher rpm hp peak is 4200rpm on the 8.1
edmunds results from full test of a 01 8.1 2500hd 2wd CCLB
01 2500hd 8.1 340/455
0 - 60 (sec.) 9.2
1/4 mile (sec. @ mph) 17.0 @ 83.9
my 02 lb7 310/520 ran 16.5 @ 85 mph in stock configure at cal speedway in 07
4x4 dmax trucks would dip into the 15s stock..
yet you say the oposite is true.. :what:
greg.. i see your point about shift and the short side not falling into peak torque range... wouldnt increase camshaft duration move everything to the right?