My alternator tach is perfectly accurate. I dialed it in with a photo tachometer and it's balls on from idle to high idle at least.
However, recently it started acting up after five years. It used to be perfectly smooth, now it's kind of sticky after 2000 RPM, but only if the alternator is on. If the alternator is off, it's smooth still. And when I turn on my 120 volt water injection it likes to get jumpy, although my digital temperature controllers both wig out due to the interference as well.
The alternator probes pick up variations in voltage (or something like that), so they should work no matter what alternator you're running. Mine works whether or not my alternator is producing any voltage at all (which struck me as weird).
The problem with the tiny tach as I see it, is that it's not a gauge face. I want a gauge face for RPM. A nice, large gauge face.