Bosshawg, skewed I think would be an understatement to what your view of my post earlier was. Obviously for the puller that does the wrench work on their truck will still have the ability and know how of what to do with a P-pump for tuning, which does have infinite tuning capabilities. My argument is that it seems like so many people that buy a 24v now a days that are getting into pulling are instantly wanting to put a P-pump on their truck because their Edge or their TST won't take them to 5000 RPM, fuel hard at 4000 RPM, or get them first place first time out. These "out of the box" pullers which have no idea of tuning and setup have someone else do the tuning for them. Most of the tuning done by these pullers are getting done at the pump shop going by combos that the shop knows have proven to work pretty good from experience on other trucks. This is a good thing, but it makes tuning from the end user near non existent if they're not a wrencher. I have full faith that pullers such as yourself and others that consistently win or do very well for that matter have and will continue to tune or play with the P-pump so they can fine tune the pump to make it work for their motor and give them the combo that gives them just a little more when and where they need it. These pullers know that a pump shop can't compensate for each engines "perks" or what they like or dislike. They know that timing as well as plate placement among many, many other little things make all the difference in the world.
The VP can be and usually is the easiest to tune for someone with some understanding of how and what goes on in it to make it work. That's the key though. There are so many that run everything they've got wide open and expect that to translate to highest power output. Just like 800cc of randomly thrown in fuel from your P-pump won't make as much power as 400cc will when tuned properly, neither will every box run wide open with lines and injectors the size of fire hoses. This is more so evident with the new common rail crowd. This is the reason for so many people not being able to keep rail pressure up. The whole "I've got a smarty that makes 230 hp on level 9 and a TST that makes 150 on level 9-9, so if I put them both on there and turn them up, I'll make 380 more hp that stock. That ought to pull the sled." mentality is what is plaguing the scene of this sport. I don't know, maybe I just get aggrivated because it seems like all everybody is worried about is who farts out the biggest cloud of smoke. Heaven forbid that they didn't win so the assumption is "I need another box". Complete truck setup or tuning in my opinion, goes way farther than just throwing parts or fuel at a problem. Sure you can't replace hp, but a properly setup 400 hp truck will consistently do better than a non setup truck making 500 hp.
The main reason I bought this truck instead of a 12V was because I liked the idea of turning my setup down to whatever level of performance I wanted and somewhat control the timing as well. This is why in my opinion, the electronic trucks can go from one extreme to the other so well. Thus making an excellent true "street puller" truck.
Sorry about my rambling. I get a little excessive in all my writing. Another reason, I usually don't get involved in these threads.
Back to topic.