Yet another "popping" problem thread...

BigBlue12V

New member
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
237
Hey guys, I have a 96 that was swapped to a p-pumped 24 valve before I got it. I've been slowly fixing some things that were not done correctly or cosmetically pleasing. It seemed very stock when I got it. The plate and starwheel were adjusted but that was it. It had a carter electric lift pump on the frame, identical to a stock 24 valve unit. I replaced that with a Holley 12-920 pump which is way more than adequate in flow and pressure for a P pump and Holley claims it is compatible for use with diesel fuels. There's a 32 micron fuel filter before the lift pump, no fuel heater bowl. The line goes straight from lift pump to fuel filter on engine (stock 12V style) then to the injection pump.

The engine is out of a Freightliner best I can tell.

A friend located and arranged the purchase of some 75hp 8 hole nozzles online, we installed those and it ran better. Upon removing the stock ones we noticed they were incredibly clogged up. I had already removed the plate and messed with the starwheel a little more before this.

Then a couple weeks ago I installed an HX40 with a 14 cm exhaust housing. With stock gov. springs I could barely get any spool from it. While doing that I also gasket matched and ported the exhaust manifold and turbo inlet/manifold flange. took it for a test drive, then installed PacBrake 4k RPM GSk, removing stock shims, then 1 soft click and 4 hard. Checked with caliper, measurements are good. At the same time, we also advance the timing. We were shooting for 22* but knowing the 24V injector pop pressure is different, we needed to add about 6.5* so we set it to 28* at the pump, which should give us 21-22 final. Upon firing it up from this, the truck idled great, but pops badly in neutral and some under load. Throughout the next week I changed the fuel filters which weren't very old, and added a fuel pressure gauge and installed a Tork Tek overflow valve. I get 40 psi of fuel pressure to the injection pump. I adjusted the AFC more as well, ground the foot and did the washer mod. I had also had a couple problems with the truck occasionally dying when coming to a stoplight and the throttle would kinda hang when starting it. So we tightened the gsk one more click each. That seemed to fix those problems. The popping persists. We checked the timing to make sure it hadn't slipped and it was still at our same setting. While doing this I remembered to check my coolant as it occasionally needs topped off, rarely takes more than a pint or so. My heater core leaks so it didn't concern me. But this time when I checked it, it was a lot lower than normal. What made me check the coolant is the fact that my temp gauge hadn't been reading anything. So we topped it off and got to wondering if the popping and more than usual coolant disappearance wasn't coolant making its way into the combustion chamber. So I replaced the head gasket and adjusted the valves. The popping was no better in neutral, but seems to be less noticable under load. Then it still wasn't registering anything on the temp gauge so I pulled the thermostat and a odd looking rubber thingy on it had gotten loose and stuck the thermostat wide open. I'm not familiar with 24V thermostats, but the aftermarket replacement one did not have this rubber piece. I installed that and all is well with the temps now.

But through all this I still have the popping. Going to mess with timing again this weekend but I'm very baffled at this point. It has to be in the timing or GSK. I know if the timing was retarded this would definitely happen but it didn't seem to have slipped. I've not really ever had or heard of this problem with GSK either, but then again I've never used or known anyone to use PacBrake kits. I've always had good luck with TST kits in the past and I'm about to rip the PB ones out and swap in TST ones for peace of mind if the timing don't fix my problem. I've done a lot of research and searching to try and find the solution to my problems.

Between the timing, head gasket, valve adjustment and all this other stuff something should have fixed it. I know ten million of ya are gonna say timing, and I hope you're right. I hope somehow we messed it up and didn't catch it when we checked it again. We kinda stopped partway through checking it because it dawned on me that my disappearing coolant was disappearing too quickly to be heater core and not making puddles so I immediately figured that was the popping problem. And BTW, the gasket was already seeping a tiny bit of oil in the front, so it wasn't done for nothing. And its good peace of mind that its new and torqued good n tight especially with more fuel and turbo going to it.

Any other ideas on what it could be, if the timing is ok? And BTW if the timing is still right where we set it, then I will drop it down some n see if that helps as a friend suggested that maybe I don't have enough fuel for that much timing (which is possible I suppose). My smoke isn't quite as black as it should be either. And my EGT's are pretty high even once I get the turbo going, I buried it at 1600 to make almost 40# of boost this evening while I was messing with it.

And while I got ya reading this (hopefully your ADD didn't kick in yet and make you hit the back button) is there any point to modifying the AFC if ya don't have a fuel plate? A friend asked me why I was modifying the AFC if I don't have a plate and it got me thinking. I'm not quite familiar enough with the insides of the P pump to really truly know the answer outright but it seems he is correct?

Thanks for all the help and sorry for the long post but figured it makes more sense to provide you with ALL the info and details now than waste your time thinking about it and typing a wrong answer or more questions.
 
I think I adjusted some load on my gov springs and stopped my popping.
 
if you havent had your injectors refreshed i would have them looked at and pop re set. That solved mine pretty good, i still get a little at 3900rpm when my springs defuel.
 
I don't know if this helps or not. But My truck ran somewhat like this for a while. In the upper rpms under load it would pop horribly and it was underpowered badly. I went through 3 sets of injectors and it changed nothing. finally got on the dyno and made a whopping 320 hp with a 66 and all the fuel I needed. Sent the pump off to Seth at DPE the next day and when I got it back it ran like a dream. He set the pump up, fixed the gov spring, balanced and flowed it.
 
Thanks for all the input guys! Again it didn't do it until we did the timing and GSK, and it was on the same tank of fuel as it had been on and ran fine off that fuel before, so hopefully I can rule out injectors. That being said, it probably wouldn't hurt to have them freshened up.

On another note, I just rotated my barrels (i know not recommended but had to try it) and let it warm up, runs pretty strong but popping is no better. Casey and Chas are on their way over with the timing kit and other stuff, we're gonna mess with the timing all over again I guess....... If that does nothing for it then we'll go through the governor springs again as well.

I think I adjusted some load on my gov springs and stopped my popping.
Were they too tight or too loose? I've heard of this being a problem before but not had any personal experience with it. I've successfully installed a few 4k kits and never had a single issue from them ever.

dieselhead, I hope it doesn't come down to that but we will see......


Thanks for all the replies!
Eric
 
Sounds like you might have the springs a little to tight.
Did you set the 4k's up and the same height as the stocks?
 
Sounds like you might have the springs a little to tight.
Did you set the 4k's up and the same height as the stocks?

Well we didn't measure the stock ones, and also we removed all stock shims.

We re-timed 'er today, set it at 18* now. It was at 22*. I've had 22* on a truck before but had larger injectors and full cut DV's, this one has 75hp nozzles and stock DV's. Anyway, the popping seems to be cured now! It runs great and pulls a lot better above 3k rpm! EGT's are a bit more tolerable as well. We were prepared to adjust GSK, but they don't seem to need it. Idle is still good, and runs like a raped ape nearly. I'm pretty happy with 'er now! Probably good for a couple hundred horse now if the clutch would hold a dyno pull :lolly::st:

Thanks for the ideas! Kinda was hoping for some other suggestions in case we either missed something or our adjustments didn't help.
 
Last edited:
Id be looking at fueling issues. These things are thirsty when you are running them hard.

With a new stock lift pump and 4k springs, my truck would start popping/stuttering pretty bad at around 3200rpm free rev and about 2900rpm or so under load. I installed my carter 4601hp in line in front of the mechanical pump because i knew the timing was good even though everyone kept saying it could be the problem, and with the extra volume running to the pump, it will free rev over 4k smooth as glass now, and pulls farther than i need it to under load. I figure if i ever up the fueling and turbo size ill need something like a FASS, but for now its working great. If you still have a stuttering problem, or run into it again, put a FASS or something similar on it and i bet that will fix it.

I think the problem is that there is a small window of time where the barrel can fill with fuel from the lift pump. If you dont have a good fuel volume and pressure coming to the pump, you cant fill the barrell fast enough. Its possible you have enough volume, but need more pressure. Your pump is only rated at 15psi, correct?
 
I swear I read somewhere that you have to run the shims with pacbrake springs to get it to run right despite the instructions...

just throwing it out there!
 
It needs to be clarified by what is meant by 'all the shims.' When you typically do gov springs, they say to leave the idle spring in place, remove the inner springs and seats. There are shims under the seats. Those are the ones to remove. If you remove the idle spring when you do this, you could also remove the idle spring shims and wear washer. The idle spring shims and wear washers should be reinstalled with the new gov springs. The small shims from the old spring seats should not, since the old seats are also not being used.
 
Im pretty sure it was just too much timeing for the fuel he had. we drop it to 18* and it didnt pop any more. I did his springs per pac brake directions. we set the height at .48 on both sides and then later went one click due to erratic idle with the idle bolt being tight. Mine did the same thing for about a week the idle would change daily and my idle adj bolt was locked down good.
 
Id be looking at fueling issues. These things are thirsty when you are running them hard.....

Its possible you have enough volume, but need more pressure. Your pump is only rated at 15psi, correct?


I replaced that with a Holley 12-920 pump which is way more than adequate in flow and pressure for a P pump and Holley claims it is compatible for use with diesel fuels. There's a 32 micron fuel filter before the lift pump, no fuel heater bowl. The line goes straight from lift pump to fuel filter on engine (stock 12V style) then to the injection pump....

Throughout the next week I changed the fuel filters which weren't very old, and added a fuel pressure gauge and installed a Tork Tek overflow valve. I get 40 psi of fuel pressure to the injection pump.


I think you're trying to confuse me, or you're confused one of the two. I did not mention that my lift pump is rated for 80 PSI, however I did mention that I'm putting 40 psi to the injection pump under load. From my understanding and research, stock overflow valve and lift pump are good for about 22 PSI and I don't recall how much volume off top of my head, but it was a good bit less than my Holley puts out. I don't have and can't run a mechanical lift pump due to my engine configuration.
 
I think you're trying to confuse me, or you're confused one of the two. I did not mention that my lift pump is rated for 80 PSI, however I did mention that I'm putting 40 psi to the injection pump under load. From my understanding and research, stock overflow valve and lift pump are good for about 22 PSI and I don't recall how much volume off top of my head, but it was a good bit less than my Holley puts out. I don't have and can't run a mechanical lift pump due to my engine configuration.

Sorry, I didnt see the part where you said you are getting 40psi. I just googled the pump and it said 15psi was what it put out? It could have been wrong though. I think the stock lift pump is 18-24 psi at idle, 28-36 at 2000 rpm with no load, and can go up some from there with RPM. Regardless, 40psi is plenty as long as you have enough volume.
 
It needs to be clarified by what is meant by 'all the shims.' When you typically do gov springs, they say to leave the idle spring in place, remove the inner springs and seats. There are shims under the seats. Those are the ones to remove. If you remove the idle spring when you do this, you could also remove the idle spring shims and wear washer. The idle spring shims and wear washers should be reinstalled with the new gov springs. The small shims from the old spring seats should not, since the old seats are also not being used.

Tate, if you could just repost this 5,000 times on the internet, 90% of the "Installed GSK, now runs like crap" posts would stop.
 
What do these wear washers look like? When i did my GSK there were three "washers" one shim the same diameter as the idle spring and narrow like the idle spring and then 2 (one each side) that where the same outside diameter but thicker meaning the opeing was smaller in the center where the seat would sit and be shimmed. Are those the wear washers you are describing as I never found any other washers or shims in mine?
 
Tate, if you could just repost this 5,000 times on the internet, 90% of the "Installed GSK, now runs like crap" posts would stop.

I might get banned for post whoring, but I'll do my best.

What do these wear washers look like? When i did my GSK there were three "washers" one shim the same diameter as the idle spring and narrow like the idle spring and then 2 (one each side) that where the same outside diameter but thicker meaning the opeing was smaller in the center where the seat would sit and be shimmed. Are those the wear washers you are describing as I never found any other washers or shims in mine?

The one with the same OD as the idle spring but with the small ID is the wear washer. Prevents any damage to the flyweight assembly from the springs. Wear washer and idle spring should go back in.
 
Is the hole in the wear washer the same size as the stud or is it bigger? The one I left out has the hole just a bit smaller than the spring seat but basically if the OD of the washer is the same as the idle spring it stays. Anything smaller comes out. Looks like I'm diving back into the GSK tonight. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Well the wife took the camera so no pics.....I did pull the GSK out today and put the washers and idle shim back in. I have always had a surge when I set the cruise after I did the gsk initially. That is now gone. I always fugured it was just part of modifying the pump and engine....
 
Back
Top