White Duramax
New member
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2007
- Messages
- 452
How can a F450 be a 1 ton or less truck? Why would Ford build a F350 and a F450 if they were the same truck, just different badges? Come on.
Leadfoot, you're a quarter inch away from writing a rule that says "acceptable rear ends: Dana 80 and AAM 11.5".
I say if a 450 can make weight than let it pull. I think all this discussion about axle size is pointless. It isn't the axle that is going to make the truck take first place at a pull. It is just a stronger axle. It could break as easily as any other axle or it could last longer. Whining because for say you got beat by an f-450 because it has a bigger axle isn't any different than a guy whining because he still runs a d70 and he got beat by a guy with a d80. If he got beat by a guy with a d80 but his d70 axle didn't break than how did that d80 become the deciding factor.
Gears, Tuning, Driving style, Luck etc... That is the deciding factor in who comes in first and who whines. My .02
When a guy spends $2500 to make his d80 stay together, and then you say hey you can run a 1.25 ton truck, yea that is a big difference.
The guy with $2500 in his d80 probably didn't start off with a truck that cost over 40k either so he could afford to put his money where it matters. It still doesn't mean the bigger axle is going to make that truck a winner.
If a f-450 was allowed in and the change was made would alot of guys ditch there d70,d80,AAM, Sterling axles for the bigger 110 or not? Me personally, I haven't got alot of money in my d80 and have been lucky. I could also pick up a 110 fairly cheap from just down the road. I would swap.
How do you know the guy with the D80 or the 11.5 doesn't have $40K? I saw a 2011 dodge 3500 the other day for $55K.
Sad part is a stock D80 on a good track at 800+ hp probably won't last more than 10 hooks. I have seen some of them break at 600HP. It isn't truck setup that breaks them either(well I guess you could put some 215/85/16 on them and they would live)
I don't have an issue with a 450 frame pulling, but it needs to have a driveline/motor combination that was available in a 350 or smaller.
I am just saying that at some point the sport has to move forward with the times as the trucks get newer or it will be antique diesel truck pulling. I don't have a problem with an f-450 pulling in the same class as I do regardless of anything. If I was to get beat by a 450 due to distance than so be it. It isn't because his driveline is stronger than mine.
Come back and say that when your trying to put 1000HP+ through an OEM driveline.
Let the f-450 hook in workstock, but not in a class where you have to build the truck.
I won't ever be putting down 1000+hp period for workstock or 2.6 which is what I run. I'm more involved in tractor pulling anyway but if someone wants to put money into a 40k+ 450 to pull 2.6 than I say go ahead. Does not make a hill of beans difference to me.
Like said its peoples opinion not a proven fact it isn't legal. By all the paper work I have read it makes it legal.
The Dana/Spicer Model S110 is an automotive axle manufactured by the Dana Corp. and the Eaton Corporation. Eaton manufacturers the carrier and Dana manufacturers the rest of the axle. The S110 model follows a newer nomenclature for Dana axles. The "S" meaning: single rear axle. The first "1" representing gear reduction type, the second representing the head assembly series and the last "0" representing the design level.
The Dana S110 is used in Class 4 and Class 5 applications. Dodge, Ford and General Motors use this axle as well as various other companies. The Dana S110 is a full floating, drop-out axle. Dana S110 axles are a step up in overall strength compared to the Dana 80. Ford started using this axle in 2005 model F-450 and F-550 trucks, while Dodge started using the Dana S110 in their 2008 model 4500 and 5500 trucks. Although this axle is designed for medium-duty, commercial-trucks, Ford does put the S110 in F-450 Pick up trucks. The Dana S110 has a gross weight rating up to 14,500 lbs but is frequently, de-rated by vehicle manufacturer for safety and tire reasons. This axle is not yet used in 1 Ton trucks (Class 3).